The Influencer Marketing Bubble

The Desiree Team
August 15, 2023
The question of whether influencer marketing is a sustainable strategy or a short-term hype is a topic of ongoing debate. While influencer marketing has gained significant popularity and success in recent years, it is essential to evaluate its long-term viability and effectiveness.

Influencer marketing, a sustainable strategy

Proponents of influencer marketing argue that it can be a sustainable strategy. They highlight several reasons:

Relatable content

Influencer marketing leverages authenticity and trust. Influencers often have a dedicated following that trusts their recommendations. By partnering with influencers, brands can tap into this trust to create authentic and relatable content, fostering long-term brand loyalty.

Targeted reach

Influencers have the ability to reach niche audiences that may be challenging to target through traditional advertising. This targeted approach enables brands to connect with specific customer segments effectively.


Influencers are skilled at creating engaging content and telling compelling stories. This storytelling ability allows brands to establish deeper connections with their target audience, fostering stronger brand-consumer relationships.

#morphe on Instagram

Measurable ROI

Campaigns can be tracked and measured using various metrics such as reach, engagement, click-through rates, and conversions. This data-driven approach enables brands to assess the effectiveness of their campaigns and make data-backed decisions.

71%+ Measure the ROI on Their Influencer Marketing

Or short-term hype?

However, there are also skeptics who view influencer marketing as a short-term hype. They raise the following concerns:

Saturation and authenticity

With the increasing popularity of influencer marketing, some argue that the market may become oversaturated with influencers promoting various products. This saturation can lead to reduced authenticity and audience trust, ultimately diminishing the effectiveness of influencer campaigns.


With more users actively avoiding advertisements, there is a risk that influencer content may be ignored or skipped, resulting in wasted advertising budgets.

Ever-changing algorithms

The dynamics of social media platforms pose uncertainties. Updates to algorithms and shifts in platform dynamics can impact the visibility and reach of influencer content. This volatility makes it challenging for brands to rely solely on influencer marketing as a long-term strategy.

Measurable ROI... or not?

Lastly, there are measurement and return on investment (ROI) challenges. While measurement metrics exist, accurately attributing the impact of influencer marketing on sales and revenue can be complex. Determining the true ROI and the incremental value generated from influencer campaigns remains a challenge for many brands.

Ultimately, the sustainability of influencer marketing as a long-term strategy depends on how brands adapt and evolve their approaches. Building genuine relationships with influencers, maintaining authenticity, focusing on audience engagement, and continuously evaluating and adjusting strategies will be key factors in sustaining the effectiveness of influencer marketing over time. The ongoing debate surrounding this topic reflects the need for a thoughtful and strategic approach to influencer marketing as brands navigate the evolving landscape of digital advertising.


The ultimate guide for the modern brand owner, delivered straight to your inbox.
Thank you for subscribing!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Share button